Have you ever received a call from staffing agencies or hiring managers that clearly undervalued your skill level? It’s pretty disappointing to get a call from your dream company in the hopes of being interviewed for that Executive Management position only to find they want to meet with you for their Executive Assistant job.
You don’t want that job but you want to work for the company. How do you gracefully decline an opportunity that you’re overqualified for?
Thrivas, a leader among staffing agencies in Broward County, has a few tips. These tips are directly from our recruiters. Yep, they may have called you and misread a key point on your resume or overlooked your education achievements in error. We may have gotten the hopes up for applicants who knew we were recruiting for a certain Fortune 500 company or international organization that they want to be a part of. Only to find the employment opportunity does not suit their skill level or experience. Although it is very rare, we have made mistakes.
The job seekers who get angry and rush off the phone in a huff (appalled that an error could be made regarding their amazingness) may never get a return call. When that dream job does finally open up the job seeker will be remembered as unprofessional and emotionally incapable of handling sour situations in a positive manner. Hanging up on the staffing agency that is recruiting for your dream company? That’s not very harmonious with the “able to work well under pressure” or “poised, professional and level headed in the most stressful situations” that you have typed out on your resume.
So how do you handle this delicate situation in the hopes of being considered for employment opportunities that meet your expectations, salary or career goals? Well, our Broward County Staffing Agency has had some great responses that earned a call back and it was because the approach was so tactful we said, “Wow, now that’s a professional. Let me earmark that resume”. That person went from undervalued to our go-to resume for the next opening.
A simple statement such as “I am so glad you called. I have done a lot of research on your company and would love to be considered, however I feel that (XYZ qualifications) would make me more suited for a position such as…” or a more direct but tactful response “Although my qualifications and salary make me overqualified for this particular position I would like to have my information kept on file with your company. Possibly for (XYZ opportunity).
This allows you to decline in a way that does not embarrass the recruiter for their error while offering you the opportunity to outline your skill set AND take a moment to outline where your interests are with the staffing company.
Find a job by searching below
- Patient Service Representative
quantum-health — Dublin,OHDescription At a Glance ...
- Warehouse Supervisor
Ace Hardware Corporation — West Jefferson,OHWarehouse Supervisor Multiple shift opportunities available What You'll Do ...
- Delivery Driver
The Aaron's Company — Columbus,OHThe hourly range for this position is $14.75 to $15.50. ...
- Asset Manager
Wallick Communities — New Albany,OHDescription Asset Manager Location: Wallick Corporate Office (New Albany, OH) Job Type: Full-Time Make a Difference—And Own Your Future Join Wallick Communities, a 100% employee-owned company with over...
- In Home Caregiver
Home Instead — Grove City,OHWhat is Home Instead? Home Instead is a home care company that values passion and rewards caregivers with competitive benefits. Home Instead provides a variety of non-medical services that allow...
- Automotive Fleet Mechanic C
Transdev — Columbus,OHTransdev in Columbus, Ohio is seeking a C-Level Diesel Mechanic to bolster our team that is working with our COTA contract. This role demands expertise in diagnosing, repairing, and maintaining...
- Social Media Manager (Volunteer/Remote)
Abuse Refuge Org — Westerville,OHCompany Description About Abuse Refuge Org: ARO focuses on championing 28 areas of abuse including Narcissism, Sexual, Physical, Psychological, Financial, Child, Self, Cyberbullying (Including Online Abuse), Bullying,...
- Senior Multifamily Acquisitions Leader
National Church Residences — Columbus,OHJob Description: SENIOR PROJECT LEADER - ACQUISITIONS POSITION PURPOSE: The Senior Project Leader - Acquisitions will be accountable for the...
- Project Manager
W3R Consulting — Columbus,OHTitle: Project Manager Location: Columbus, Ohio Duration: 5 months contract + likely to extend 📋 Project Manager – Federal Grant & Loan Application...
- Personal Banker Associate II - Jerome Village; Plain City, OH
Fifth Third Bank — Dublin,OHMake banking a Fifth Third better® We connect great people to great opportunities. Are you ready to take the next step? Discover a career in banking at Fifth Third Bank....
- Construction Assistant Project Manager Internship for Students- Fall 2025 (full-time/part-time)
Superior — Columbus,OHPosition: Assistant Project Manager Intern Location: Columbus, Ohio Pay Range: $19 - $22 per hour Superior is looking for highly motivated and energetic students to participate in our...
- Quality Manager
Jobot — Canal Winchester,OHManufacturing Quality Manager needed for reputable, high growth automotive & plastics injection molding manufacturer! This Jobot Job is hosted by: Colin Callahan Are you a fit? Easy Apply now by...
- Director of Operations
Percy — Columbus,OHAt Percy, we're dedicated to connecting talented professionals with exceptional career opportunities. We're currently partnering with a dynamic and growing organization seeking a proactive and strategic Director of Operations to...
- English Teacher 2025-2026 SY Northwoods CPHS
Life Skills High School — Columbus,OHAbout the Organization At Career Prep schools we make a generational change by caring enough about each student to give them a personal, career-focused graduation plan and then helping them...
- IS Application Manager – Senior
S3 Connections LLC — Columbus,OHJob Title: IS Application Manager – Senior Location: Columbus, OH (100% Onsite – 5 Days/Week Required) Duration: 6 Months (Contract) Rate: Up to $55-60/hr to w2 or 1099 Citizenship Requirement:...
- Assistant/Associate Engineer, Analytics Management - Power BI (Remote)
Abercrombie & Fitch Company — Columbus,OHCompany Description. As a member of the Analytics Management team, this position is responsible for executing the development & support of our BI solutions. This position will work closely with...
- Instructional Designer
Insight Global — Columbus,OHJob Title: Instructional Designer & Courseware Developer Location: Columbus OH 43219 Hours: Monday-Friday, 8:00am-5:00pm, all in person Pay Rate:...
- Case Manager- Columbus, Ohio Fresh Start- 1st shift
Volunteers of America Greater Ohio & Indiana — Columbus,OHThe Case Manager will be responsible for developing service plans designed to ensure stable, permanent housing and monitoring of our clients for up to six months. Incumbent acts as an...
- Human Resources Coordinator - $5,000 Hiring Bonus
Uline — West Jefferson,OHContact candidates to schedule interviews, answer candidate questions and assist new hires with onboarding documents. Conduct candidate pre-employment assessments and maintain accurate candidate records. Communicate candidate details to interview...
- Director of Datacenters
Placed — New Albany,OHJob Summary: Manage all operational aspects of the market and organize operational staff to ensure all projects are carried out effectively and efficiently, promoting customer satisfaction and ensuring that project...
- Administrative Support Specialist - CO
Dublin City Schools — Dublin,OHTo assist and relieve administrative supervisor(s) of paper work and impediments utilizing efficient methods through the use of technology so that he/she may devote maximum attention to the central problems...
- Payroll Manager / Healthcare / Hospital
Personnel Resources — Columbus,OHTITLE: Payroll Manager / Healthcare / HospitalLocation: Columbus, OH Now is your chance to join a Forbes magazine top 100 hospital where career growth and opportunity await you.They are committed...
- Cognos Data Engineer
Ascyndent — Columbus,OHAt Ascyndent we believe Digital transformation is all about leveraging information and technology to enhance the human experience. It is also about transformative execution. Our teams bring business visions and...
- Construction Project Manager
HGC Construction — Columbus,OHWe are seeking an experienced and driven Project Manager to join our dynamic team. In this pivotal role, you will oversee the construction projects from conception to completion, ensuring they...
- Vendor Management Analyst
Pearson — Columbus,OH1 week ago Be among the first 25 applicantsLocation: RemoteAt Pearson, we're committed to a world that's always learning and to our talented team who makes it all possible. We...
- Customs and Border Protection Officer
U.S. Customs and Border Protection — Columbus,OHU.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) offers those interested in a career in law enforcement an exceptional opportunity to work with an elite team of highly trained professionals whose camaraderie,...
- Customer Success Engineer, Data Center Learning
Amazon — Dublin,OHAWS Infrastructure Services owns the design, planning, delivery, and operation of all AWS global infrastructure. In other words, were the people who keep the cloud running. We support all AWS...
- Project Manager, Planning
Central Ohio Transit Authority — Columbus,OHSALARY: $81,702.40-$96,137.60LOCATION: 33 N. High St. Columbus, OH 43215BENEFITS:* Medical, Vision, Dental, Supplemental and Life Insurance* Paid Parental Leave* Employee Discounts* COTA Bus Pass* Wellness Initiatives* On-Site Chair Massage* On-Site...
- Construction Project Executive - Columbus, OH
model group — Columbus,OHRecognized as a Top Workplace in Cincinnati from 2021 - 2025 ABOUT US Model Group is an employee-owned real estate construction, development and management company with its headquarters in Cincinnati,...
- Director of Property Accounting
Equity Commercial Real Estate Solutions — Columbus,OHLet Us Tell You About this Position: Equity ECS is a full service commercial real estate firm. Our comprehensive platform includes development, construction, brokerage, and property management services that are...
- OSP Director of Operations
TelForce Group LLP — Columbus,OHTelForce Group is seeking: Director of Operations Regional Construction Managers 8 Years minimum experience Manage KPI's – Direct Reports THESE...
- Legal Billing Specialist
Jobot — Columbus,OHOnsite - Legal Billing Specialist for Established Firm - Up to $75k + Profit Sharing!! This Jobot Job is hosted by: Lisa Maloney Are you a fit? Easy Apply now...
- Third Party Risk Management Analyst
Infinite computer Solutions — Columbus,OHWe're seeking for an Third Party Risk Management Analyst for our direct client. Please review the below job Description and revert with your interest for the same. Job details: Role:...
- Associate Executive Director - Eldon and Elsie Ward Family YMCA
YMCA — Columbus,OHAt the YMCA, we are united by a deep commitment to strengthening our communityand were looking for a passionate and purpose-driven leader to join us in that mission. As Associate...
- Parent Educator/Case Manager (CDCA)
maryhaven — Dublin,OHParent Educator/Case Manager (CDCA) Requirements Associate arts or bachelors degree in human service or behavioral science with one (1) year of experience in the field of chemical dependence or...
- Associate Center Director
Octapharma Plasma — Columbus,OHHow to Maximize your opportunity to do rewarding work, your future leadership potential, and your career growth? Join an industry leader. [Become one, too!] Want to be a part of...
- Programmer/Analyst: III (Senior)
Genesis10 — Columbus,OHGenesis10 is seeking a Programmer/Analyst: III (Senior) for a hybrid 3-month contract to hire position with a leading client in Columbus, OH. Compensation: $58.00-68.00 per hour W2. Job Description: We...
- Project Manager - Commercial Construction
EngTal — Columbus,OHProject Manager (Commercial Construction) Location: Columbus, OH | Salary: $115,000–$155,000+ base + bonus + profit sharing About the Company: This Columbus-based...
- Procurement Analyst
Apex Systems — New Albany,OHProcurement Analyst Opportunity Seeking a Procurement Analyst to join a company in the greater Columbus area. Supports Procurement Consultants, Procurement Specialists, and Category Managers in the execution of sourcing and...
- Medicaid/Medicare Accounts Receivable Director
Medasource — Columbus,OH23 hours ago Be among the first 25 applicants Get AI-powered advice on this job and more exclusive features. Our large Healthcare client is seeking a Medicaid/Medicare Director for a...