Have you ever received a call from staffing agencies or hiring managers that clearly undervalued your skill level? It’s pretty disappointing to get a call from your dream company in the hopes of being interviewed for that Executive Management position only to find they want to meet with you for their Executive Assistant job.
You don’t want that job but you want to work for the company. How do you gracefully decline an opportunity that you’re overqualified for?
Thrivas, a leader among staffing agencies in Broward County, has a few tips. These tips are directly from our recruiters. Yep, they may have called you and misread a key point on your resume or overlooked your education achievements in error. We may have gotten the hopes up for applicants who knew we were recruiting for a certain Fortune 500 company or international organization that they want to be a part of. Only to find the employment opportunity does not suit their skill level or experience. Although it is very rare, we have made mistakes.
The job seekers who get angry and rush off the phone in a huff (appalled that an error could be made regarding their amazingness) may never get a return call. When that dream job does finally open up the job seeker will be remembered as unprofessional and emotionally incapable of handling sour situations in a positive manner. Hanging up on the staffing agency that is recruiting for your dream company? That’s not very harmonious with the “able to work well under pressure” or “poised, professional and level headed in the most stressful situations” that you have typed out on your resume.
So how do you handle this delicate situation in the hopes of being considered for employment opportunities that meet your expectations, salary or career goals? Well, our Broward County Staffing Agency has had some great responses that earned a call back and it was because the approach was so tactful we said, “Wow, now that’s a professional. Let me earmark that resume”. That person went from undervalued to our go-to resume for the next opening.
A simple statement such as “I am so glad you called. I have done a lot of research on your company and would love to be considered, however I feel that (XYZ qualifications) would make me more suited for a position such as…” or a more direct but tactful response “Although my qualifications and salary make me overqualified for this particular position I would like to have my information kept on file with your company. Possibly for (XYZ opportunity).
This allows you to decline in a way that does not embarrass the recruiter for their error while offering you the opportunity to outline your skill set AND take a moment to outline where your interests are with the staffing company.
Find a job by searching below
- Warehouse Associate
KSI Collision Parts — Columbus,OHJob Description As a Warehouse Associate at KSI Auto Parts, you will be responsible for efficiently loading, unloading, staging, picking, and packing in our distribution center. Your role will support...
- Remote Customer Service Representative
Conduent — Columbus,OHThrough our dedicated associates, Conduent delivers mission-critical services and solutions on behalf of Fortune 100 companies and over 500 governments - creating exceptional outcomes for our clients and the millions...
- Grocery Merchandiser
DELALLO GROUP — Columbus,OHDeLallo Grocery Merchandisers provide the ultimate shopping experience by helping to maintain our products in our customer's stores, cultivate relationships with customer contacts, and build creative and visually appealing display...
- Purchasing Coordinator
ODL — Grove City,OHPrimary responsibilities will involve sourcing suppliers, managing vendor relationships, and ensuring timely and cost-effective procurement. You will work closely with the Purchasing Manager and Production team to support the company's...
- Field Service Representative
Eaton — Worthington,OHEaton's ES AMER ESS division is currently seeking a Field Service Representative. This role is located out of Worthington, OH. Field Service Representative roles offer company car and guaranteed 40-hour...
- Janitorial Dayporter
ServiceMaster — Groveport,OHHiring Now-Part-time-Dayshift -Monday-Friday 9AM-1PM-Job duties consist of mopping, sweeping, dusting, vacuuming, and cleaning of restrooms. Provide several nights of training and consistent coaching by a highly trained supervisor. ...
- Laundry Attendant
Drury Hotels Company, LLC — Dublin,OHPerforms a variety of laundry duties to provide clean and sanitary linens and terry for our guests including but not limited to washing, drying, sorting, folding and inspecting items for...
- Online Order Filling Team Associate
Walmart — Grove City,OHHourly Wage: $15 - $28 per/hour *The actual hourly rate will equal or exceed the required minimum wage applicable to the job location. Additional compensation includes annual or quarterly performance...
- Food Packer
AVI Foodsystems — Gahanna,OHAVI Foodsystems is looking for an energetic and optimistic team member to immediately fill the role of Food Packer, Part-time. Founded in 1960, AVI Foodsystems has evolved into one of...
- Forklift Operators
Remedy Staffing — Grove City,OHDescription New facility in Grove City seeking skilled Sit-Down Clamp Forklift Operators to join the team! Job Title: Forklift Operator - Sit-Down Clamp Shifts Available: ...
- Customer Service Representative (Remote)
Recruit Monitor — Columbus,OHAbout the job Customer Service Representative (Remote) Paychex Performance-Based Culture is where the great work and innovations of our people are seen, fueled, and rewarded. We accomplish this by creating...
- Warehouse Associate
Chadwell Supply — Canal Winchester,OHSmart, Innovative, and Hard-working? Perfect! We are growing and need the right people with the right mindset. Join our family and find a home where you will enjoy working with...
- Brand Ambassador
IDT — Columbus,OHIDT's Retail division is looking for Brand Ambassadors ("BA"). IDT is a leading communications and financial services company looking for enthusiastic and energetic Brand Ambassadors Responsibilities: ...
- Movers/Helpers Wanted
ALL MY SONS MOVING & STORAGE — Gahanna,OH**ONSITE JOB OFFERS!!!** Hiring Helpers We make it fast and easy to start working!! Pre-qualify within minutes!! Helpers Pay: Paid Weekly • $12 to $14 per hour...
- Warehouse Associate
Geodis — Columbus,OHDescription WAREHOUSE ASSOCIATE/MATERIAL HANDLER Shifts/Schedules Shift Details: Monday to Friday 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM Text DELIVER to...
- Remote - Customer Service Representative
Teleperformance — Columbus,OHCategory : Customer Service/Support About TP TP is a global, digital business services company. We deliver the most advanced, digitally powered business services to help the world's...
- Mortgage Underwriter
SolomonEdwards — Columbus,OHAbout Us SolomonEdwardsGroup, LLC ("SolomonEdwards") is a full-service professional services firm offering financial, operational, and technology consulting and operations support. We work with some of the world's most prominent companies...
- Survey Manager
Medium — Columbus,OHWhat We Offer Our excellent salary and benefits package includes medical, dental, vision, life insurance, short and long?term disability coverage, education reimbursement, 401(k), performance bonuses, and an employee stock program.
- Remote Customer Service Representative - OH & PA
NiSource — Columbus,OHJoin Columbia Gas, a NiSource company, as a full-time Remote Customer Service Representative. In this role,you'lldeliver exceptional support by handling customer inquiries about utility bills, service requests, account transfers, and...
- Sanitation / Quality Control
National Beverage — Columbus,OHSchedule: 2nd Shift (4:00PM - 3:30AM) JOB OVERVIEW: The Quality Control Technician will be responsible for all aspects of the quality programs and functions. These include maintaining all HACCP, food...
- Housekeeping Aide
Ciena Healthcare Management — Columbus,OHDo you enjoy keeping things neat and tidy? If you have a passion for maintaining a safe, home-like environment for guests, The Laurels of West Columbus has an excellent opportunity...
- Caregiver - Weekdays, Animal Friendly
Visiting Angels — Columbus,OHExperienced Animal-Friendly Caregivers Needed in North Columbus! ($16-20/Hr Average, Weekly Pay, Start Immediately) We seek compassionate and dedicated Home Health Aides who are passionate about senior citizens...
- Material Handler - 1st Shift
NESCO Rentals — Dublin,OHPosition Summary Based on the direction and assistance of the area Specialist and Warehouse Supervisor, the Material Handler will complete the movement/shipping of materials from receiving to outbound shipments. Performs...
- Warehouse Associate
Pridestaff — Grove City,OHWarehouse Associate (Forklift Specialist) Location: Grove City, OH (Industrial Park) Shift: 1st Shift Employment Type: Full-Time...
- Ops Training Instr I
Centuri Group — Columbus,OHOps Training Instr I Date: Jan 21, 2026 Location: Columbus, OH, US, 43207 Company: NPL Construction (S4) Description: Pay Starting at: $27.00+ Centuri companies consider several factors when extending an...
- Product Development Analyst I- P&C - Westerville, OH
Accident Fund Holdings — Westerville,OHJob Description SUMMARY Product Development Analyst I is responsible for the oversight and development of new and updated products, working closely with leaders from Underwriting, Claims, Compliance,...
- Accountant
OPOC.us — Worthington,OHAccountant About Us: OPOC.us is a national, market leading organization in the areas of Employee Benefits, Retirement Plan Administration, Risk Management, and Business Success Services (HR and Payroll),...
- Patient Access Representative
Trinity Health — Grove City,OHEmployment Type: Full time Shift: Day Shift Description: Position Purpose: Patient Financial Specialist I; Ensures the collection of...
- Cleaner
Edward Rose & Sons — Dublin,OHStart with a job, stay for a career. For over 100 years, Edward Rose & Sons has been committed to career development for our team members. We offer you the...
- Merchandiser
Keurig Dr Pepper — Columbus,OHJob Overview: Merchandiser for Columbus, Hilliard, and the surrounding area Hiring Immediately The Merchandiser is responsible for providing high-quality merchandising...
- Stocker / Cashier
Petco — Columbus,OHTo perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential job duty satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable qualified individuals with disabilities to perform...
- Stock Personnel
snipes — Columbus,OHSNIPES Stock Personnel Part Time Regular We live sneakers, streetwear, and neighborhood culture! All Day! Every Day! With more than 750 stores in Europe and the USA, SNIPES is one...
- Mail Payment Operations Support Representative
Columbus Staffing — Columbus,OHMail Payment Operations Support Representative Location: 330 Rush Alley Suite 500 Columbus, OH Job Id: 957 # of Openings: 1 Formed in 1934, Telhio began as a credit union for...
- Merchandising and PIM Lead
PPG — Columbus,OHAs the Merchandizing and PIM Lead, you will be a leader supporting PIM and Marketing implementation and roll out of projects. You will support eCommerce, Marketing, and Sales within the...
- Material Handler - 2nd shift M-F 2:00pm - 10:30pm
DSV A/S — Canal Winchester,OHDSV - Global transport and logistics In 1976, ten independent hauliers joined forces and founded DSV in Denmark. Since then, DSV has evolved to become the world's 3rd largest supplier...
- Software Engineer with Security Clearance
Kudu Dynamics, LLC — Columbus,OHSoftware Engineer - Job Description Who We Are: Kudu Dynamics is a Leidos owned company, forged out of a decade of experience in computer networks and staffed with talent who...
- Mechanical Critical Facility Technician 2 - Columbus, OH with Security Clearance
M.C. Dean — Columbus,OHOverview About M.C. Dean M.C. Dean is Building Intelligence. We design, build, operate, and maintain cyber-physical solutions for the nation's most mission-critical facilities, secure environments, complex infrastructure, and global enterprises....
- Remote Bilingual Customer Service Representative
Navicore Solutions — Columbus,OHJoin the Mission. Empower Financial Wellness. Become a Bilingual Customer Service Representative at Navicore Solutions Navicore Solutions is a nonprofit organization dedicated to...
- Maintenance Technician II (3rd Shift)
Cart — Groveport,OHJob Description: Apply here to be considered for our future Maintenance Technician openings: Our Talent Acquisition team will be reviewing applicants from this posting and determining if your skills and...
- Accountant
Quantum Health — Dublin,OHDescription Who we are Founded in 1999 and headquartered in Central Ohio, we're a privately-owned, independent healthcare navigation organization. We believe that no one should have to navigate the cost...