Have you ever received a call from staffing agencies or hiring managers that clearly undervalued your skill level? It’s pretty disappointing to get a call from your dream company in the hopes of being interviewed for that Executive Management position only to find they want to meet with you for their Executive Assistant job.
You don’t want that job but you want to work for the company. How do you gracefully decline an opportunity that you’re overqualified for?
Thrivas, a leader among staffing agencies in Broward County, has a few tips. These tips are directly from our recruiters. Yep, they may have called you and misread a key point on your resume or overlooked your education achievements in error. We may have gotten the hopes up for applicants who knew we were recruiting for a certain Fortune 500 company or international organization that they want to be a part of. Only to find the employment opportunity does not suit their skill level or experience. Although it is very rare, we have made mistakes.
The job seekers who get angry and rush off the phone in a huff (appalled that an error could be made regarding their amazingness) may never get a return call. When that dream job does finally open up the job seeker will be remembered as unprofessional and emotionally incapable of handling sour situations in a positive manner. Hanging up on the staffing agency that is recruiting for your dream company? That’s not very harmonious with the “able to work well under pressure” or “poised, professional and level headed in the most stressful situations” that you have typed out on your resume.
So how do you handle this delicate situation in the hopes of being considered for employment opportunities that meet your expectations, salary or career goals? Well, our Broward County Staffing Agency has had some great responses that earned a call back and it was because the approach was so tactful we said, “Wow, now that’s a professional. Let me earmark that resume”. That person went from undervalued to our go-to resume for the next opening.
A simple statement such as “I am so glad you called. I have done a lot of research on your company and would love to be considered, however I feel that (XYZ qualifications) would make me more suited for a position such as…” or a more direct but tactful response “Although my qualifications and salary make me overqualified for this particular position I would like to have my information kept on file with your company. Possibly for (XYZ opportunity).
This allows you to decline in a way that does not embarrass the recruiter for their error while offering you the opportunity to outline your skill set AND take a moment to outline where your interests are with the staffing company.
Find a job by searching below
- In-Store Appointment Setter
ARS — Columbus,OHColumbus Worthington Air ...
- Airship Crew
Goodyear — Columbus,OHAs an Airship Crew member, you will play a key role in supporting the safe and efficient operation of the Goodyear Blimp while traveling nationwide. You will contribute to all...
- Senior Program Manager - Logistics Startups
Ryder System — Columbus,OH_Job Seekers can review the Job Applicant Privacy Policy by clicking here ( ._Job Description :We are hiring a Senior Program Manager - Logistics Startups supporting startup operations for our...
- Grill Cook
Bob Evans Restaurants — Columbus,OHPay Range $14 - $18 per hour depending on geographic location and local market demand Early Close / No late nights Great Work Life Balance Career Growth Opportunities Excellent Benefits...
- Dockworker (Hostler) - Afternoon Shift
XPO — Columbus,OHWhat you'll need to succeed as a Dockworker (Hostler) at XPOMinimum qualifications:* Be at least 18 years of age* A valid driver's license* Able to do basic math calculations, with...
- Overnight Team Member
McDonald’s — Columbus,OHFlexible scheduling with a side of always feeling valued. McDonald's offers a job combo that will fit YOU.This position is for overnight shifts only.Perks & Benefits:* Pay starting at $11.50...
- Server Assistant - Busser
Texas Roadhouse Holdings LLC — Grove City,OHAt Texas Roadhouse, we are a people-first company that just happens to serve steaks. Legendary Food and Legendary Service is who we are. We're about loving what you're doing today...
- Customer Service Representative
Vista Packaging and Logistics — Columbus,OHDescription The Account Manager will be an essential team member focused on customer service through inputting orders, client communication, work order releases, due date management, and organization. This key associate...
- Forklift Operator - 2nd Shift
Abbott — Columbus,OHAbbott is a global healthcare leader that helps people live more fully at all stages of life. Our portfolio of life-changing technologies spans the spectrum of healthcare, with leading businesses...
- CDL-A Truck Driver - Home Daily - $10k Sign-On
SYSCO — Galloway,OHSysco is Now Hiring Local CDL-A Delivery Drivers in Columbus, OH!Home Daily - Earn Up to $100,000/Year* - Up to $10,000 Sign-On Bonus*...
- Part Time Food Production
Gordon Food Service — Columbus,OHGordon Food Service Store LLCLocation: 5700 Columbus Sq, Columbus, OH, 43231Now Hiring!Pay: $13/hr* Store Hours - Monday through Saturday 7AM-8PM; Sunday 9AM-6PM* Holidays Off - We are CLOSED on Thanksgiving,...
- Daytime Team Member
Potbelly — Columbus,OHPAY TRANSPARENCY: earn between $13.75 and $14.25 plus digital tips!* Do you hunger for more? Potbelly Sandwich Shop is looking for friendly and outgoing people who enjoy working in a...
- Inventory Specialist
Walgreens — Columbus,OH* Responsible for executing, monitoring, and training inventory best practices and standard operating procedures for the entire store, including both front end and pharmacy. Supports pharmacy inventory management activities, including...
- Customer Service Rep $19.15/hr
Veterans Sourcing Group — Columbus,OHCustomer Service Rep - $19.15/hr Columbus, OH Preference for 1 of the following criteria: • College Degree • Previous contact center experience Position Description Client Support Service...
- Work From Home Earn Part Time Income Side Income - Focus Group Panelist Needed (up to $750/week)
Apex Focus Group — Columbus,OHSeeking motivated individuals to participate in National Focus Groups and Clinical Trial studies. Earn up to $750/week in your spare time. Must register and apply to see if you qualify.
- Customer Service Representative
Vista Packaging Logistics — Columbus,OHThe Account Manager will be an essential team member focused on customer service through inputting orders, client communication, work order releases, due date management, and organization. This key associate will...
- Customer Service Representative
POOLCORP — Columbus,OHLocation: Columbus, OH - 39, 1758 Westbelt Dr., Columbus, Ohio - 43228Pay: $20/ hour and up to $2,500 through our performance bonuses.Work Hours: Monday-Friday 8am-5pmYou want Benefits? You've got it!...
- Warehouse Associate, Inbound
Cardinal Health — Columbus,OHJob DescriptionSchedule: Monday- Friday 5:30AM - 1:30PM or until the work is completed, overtime expectedWhat Warehouse Operations Contribute to Cardinal HealthWarehouse Operations ensures an uninterrupted flow of life saving drugs...
- Substitute Food Service
Worthington City Schools — Columbus,OHPosition Type: CLASSIFIED SUPPORT STAFF/SUBSTITUTE Non-Certified/Food Service - Substitute Date Posted: 7/8/2025 Location: Food Services Date...
- Vendor Managed Inventory Specialist
MSC Industrial Supply — Columbus,OH**BUILD A BETTER CAREER WITH MSC**Serving customers and our community starts with the best people doing their best work. That is precisely what we have created at MSC Industrial Supply...
- Store Delivery Driver - Part Time
Fisher Auto Parts — Columbus,OHDescription KEY RESPONSIBILITIES: The Delivery Driver will deliver parts to a pre-determined group of customers. The driver should be friendly and courteous and should have the ability to work with...
- Warehouse Security Officer
Securitas — Columbus,OHWarehouse Security OfficerWage: $17.00/ hourRequirements:* 0-2 years of security experience.* Highly reliable with the ability to adapt to various site demands.* Must be flexible and willing to work at different...
- Crew Manager
White Castle — Columbus,OHWhite Castle, America's first fast food restaurant, is over 103 years old and looking for friendly, fun and energetic Crew Managers!Our Crew Managers have previous food service or management experience...
- Food Prep/Pantry
Jeff Ruby Culinary Entertainment — Columbus,OHPosition Overview: To assist the chefs by preparing ingredients, keeping kitchen clean and orderly, and by performing some of the simpler cooking functions as assigned according to the menu, which...
- Prep Cooks
O'Charley's — Reynoldsburg,OHO'Charley's - 2272 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Road - Responsibilities: Prepare ingredients and cook dishes to O'Charley's standards in a high-volume kitchen ...
- Line Cook
NO SOLICITING — Columbus,OHJOB DESCRIPTION: We are searching for an experienced Line Cook to join our No Soliciting culinary team in a fine dining setting. The ideal candidate will be able to deliver...
- Customer Service Associate
American Signature — Columbus,OHDescription At American Signature Inc., we believe everyone has the right to a well-furnished life. Every day, our customers embark upon their personal style journey-an adventure. To that purpose, we...
- Service Center Operator A
RYERSON — Columbus,OHService Center Operator AReq Id: 2646Workplace Type: On-SiteJob Shift: 1stBrand: RyersonJob Location: ColumbusPosting Start Date: 5/29/26SummaryWelcome to Ryerson, where exceptional career opportunities await. As a leading provider of industrial...
- Retail Sales Associate
Marshalls — Columbus,OHMarshallsAt TJX Companies, every day brings new opportunities for growth, exploration, and achievement. You'll be part of our vibrant team that embraces diversity, fosters collaboration, and prioritizes your...
- Prep Cook
RH — Columbus,OHWith over 20 Hospitality experiences worldwide, RH Hospitality continues to expand our distinguished portfolio of Restaurants within our Design Galleries globally. Our goal is to blur the line between home...
- Stock Worker and Receiver
Sodexo S A — Columbus,OHStock Worker and ReceiverLocation: ACCENT US DUMMY - 12608001Workdays/shifts: Weekdays - morning shifts. More details will be provided during the interview process.Employment Type: Full-timePay Range: $20 per hour - $22...
- Operator - 3rd Shift
Lancaster Colony Corporation — Columbus,OHAbout UsThe Marzetti Company (Nasdaq: MZTI) manufactures and sells specialty food products. Our retail brands include Marzetti dressings and dips, New York Bakery garlic breads, and Sister Schubert's dinner rolls,...
- Dialysis Program Manager Registered Nurse - RN
FRESENIUS — Columbus,OHPURPOSE AND SCOPE: Manages patient care in home therapies programs while maintaining cost-effective clinical operations. Provides direction and guidance to the interdisciplinary team providing...
- Class A Driver Direct Store Delivery - Weekly Pay
Ace Hardware — Grove City,OHCDL-A DriverWest Jefferson, OH - Ace Hardware CorporationEarn Average $103,000/Year + Safety BonusesAce Hardware is hiring CDL-A Drivers in West Jefferson, OH for direct-to-store deliveries supporting Ace retailers across the...
- Forklift Operator - Night Shift
Appleone — Columbus,OHExperienced Forklift Operator- Night Shift Position Overview Are you a skilled forklift operator seeking a night shift opportunity? Join our team and play a vital role in our logistics operations....
- Teller Retail Banker
Woodforest Bank — Columbus,OHTake the next step toward your new career today!Become a part of the diverse and inclusive team within our nationally recognized award-winning Bank that is one of the strongest in...
- Dishwasher Easton
Pies & Pints — Columbus,OHBenefits: 401(k)401(k) matchingCompany partiesDental insuranceEmployee discountsFlexible scheduleHealth insuranceOpportunity for advancementPaid time...
- Sleep Professional
Mattress Warehouse Corporate — Columbus,OHDo you want to improve lives through quality sleep? If so, we want to hear from you! At Sleep Outfitters, we have one goal: To bring our Guests and our...
- Terminal Associate
Heidelberg Materials — Columbus,OHLine of Business: OtherPay Range: $46,890.00 - $57,830.00About UsHeidelberg Materials is one of the world's largest suppliers of building materials. Heidelberg Materials North America operates over 450 locations across the...
- Pallet Sorter - Night Shift
Rehrig Pacific Company — Grove City,OHShift Details: Tuesday - Friday 4:30AM - 3:00AMPay: $18/hourGreat benefits including: Medical, Dental Vision and Life Insurance; Paid Time Off; Paid Holidays; 401k & ESOP; Profit Sharing; Tuition Reimbursement and...