Have you ever received a call from staffing agencies or hiring managers that clearly undervalued your skill level? It’s pretty disappointing to get a call from your dream company in the hopes of being interviewed for that Executive Management position only to find they want to meet with you for their Executive Assistant job.
You don’t want that job but you want to work for the company. How do you gracefully decline an opportunity that you’re overqualified for?
Thrivas, a leader among staffing agencies in Broward County, has a few tips. These tips are directly from our recruiters. Yep, they may have called you and misread a key point on your resume or overlooked your education achievements in error. We may have gotten the hopes up for applicants who knew we were recruiting for a certain Fortune 500 company or international organization that they want to be a part of. Only to find the employment opportunity does not suit their skill level or experience. Although it is very rare, we have made mistakes.
The job seekers who get angry and rush off the phone in a huff (appalled that an error could be made regarding their amazingness) may never get a return call. When that dream job does finally open up the job seeker will be remembered as unprofessional and emotionally incapable of handling sour situations in a positive manner. Hanging up on the staffing agency that is recruiting for your dream company? That’s not very harmonious with the “able to work well under pressure” or “poised, professional and level headed in the most stressful situations” that you have typed out on your resume.
So how do you handle this delicate situation in the hopes of being considered for employment opportunities that meet your expectations, salary or career goals? Well, our Broward County Staffing Agency has had some great responses that earned a call back and it was because the approach was so tactful we said, “Wow, now that’s a professional. Let me earmark that resume”. That person went from undervalued to our go-to resume for the next opening.
A simple statement such as “I am so glad you called. I have done a lot of research on your company and would love to be considered, however I feel that (XYZ qualifications) would make me more suited for a position such as…” or a more direct but tactful response “Although my qualifications and salary make me overqualified for this particular position I would like to have my information kept on file with your company. Possibly for (XYZ opportunity).
This allows you to decline in a way that does not embarrass the recruiter for their error while offering you the opportunity to outline your skill set AND take a moment to outline where your interests are with the staffing company.
Find a job by searching below
- Class A Driver Direct Store Delivery - Weekly Pay
Ace Hardware — Grove City,OHCDL-A DriverWest Jefferson, OH - Ace Hardware CorporationEarn Average $103,000/Year + Safety BonusesAce Hardware is hiring CDL-A Drivers in West Jefferson, OH for direct-to-store deliveries supporting Ace retailers across the...
- Teller Retail Banker
Woodforest Bank — Columbus,OHTake the next step toward your new career today!Become a part of the diverse and inclusive team within our nationally recognized award-winning Bank that is one of the strongest in...
- Sleep Professional
Mattress Warehouse Corporate — Columbus,OHDo you want to improve lives through quality sleep? If so, we want to hear from you! At Sleep Outfitters, we have one goal: To bring our Guests and our...
- Terminal Associate
Heidelberg Materials — Columbus,OHLine of Business: OtherPay Range: $46,890.00 - $57,830.00About UsHeidelberg Materials is one of the world's largest suppliers of building materials. Heidelberg Materials North America operates over 450 locations across the...
- Pallet Sorter - Night Shift
Rehrig Pacific Company — Grove City,OHShift Details: Tuesday - Friday 4:30AM - 3:00AMPay: $18/hourGreat benefits including: Medical, Dental Vision and Life Insurance; Paid Time Off; Paid Holidays; 401k & ESOP; Profit Sharing; Tuition Reimbursement and...
- Dock Worker
Estes Express Lines — Columbus,OH**Job Summary:**+ Properly load and unload freight using a forklift, pallet jack, hand truck or by hand+ Strap, brace and pad freight to prevent damage or shifting+ Responsible for accurately...
- Shift Leader
Insomnia Cookies — Columbus,OHAs a Shift Leader at our Columbus store located at 2209 N HIgh St, Columbus Oh 43201, you are the captain of our bakery day or night! You understand what...
- Floor Staff - GasWerks, Columbus, OH
GASWERKS — Columbus,OHJob Type Part-time Description SISTERS & BROTHERS! Brothers Bar & Grill, Columbus, OH has immediate openings for part-time Floor Staff. Floor staff assist bartenders, check ID's and work...
- Food Service Associate
Worthington Schools — Columbus,OHPosition Type:CLASSIFIED SUPPORT STAFF Non-Certified/Food ServiceDate Posted:6/5/2026Location:Wilson Hill Elementary SchoolDate Available:08/18/2026Closing Date:06/12/2026Additional Information: Show/HideFood Service Associate--Wilson HillOne...
- Underground Utility Laborer
CST Utilities — Columbus,OHUnderground Utility Laborer Company Overview CST Utilities Companies provide underground construction services (including excavation, drilling, etc.) for sites and projects related to water, sewer, natural...
- Breakfast Attendant
Drury Hotels — Grove City,OHProperty Location:4109 Parkway Centre Drive - Grove City, Ohio 43123You belong at Drury Hotels.Getting a job is just the beginning. Finding a place where you belong is what truly matters....
- Customer Service Representative
Circle K Stores — Columbus,OHStore 2743519: 4758 West Broad, Columbus, Ohio 43228Shift AvailabilityDays & EveningsTime TypePart timeESSENTIAL DUTIES:The position includes, but is not limited to, the following essential job duties, responsibilities and requirements:Customer...
- Customer Service Associate II
Dollar Tree — Columbus,OHYour positive, friendly disposition and eagerness to get things done make you the right person for our Customer Service Associate II position. Join our team today and let's create an...
- Shift Leader
Playa Bowls — Columbus,OHABOUT THE COMPANYPlaya Bowls is New Jersey's Original Acai Shop, founded in 2014, and our mission is to bring superfruit bowls to the masses using only the freshest, highest quality...
- Cleaning Crew
Pins Mechanical — Columbus,OHAbout Pins Mechanical Co. Pins Mechanical Company & 16-Bit Bar+Arcade is a social gathering place that offers a playful alternative to a traditional night out. Whether it's duckpin bowling, pinball,...
- CDL-A Truck Driver - No Experience Needed!
Western Express — Hilliard,OHWestern Express is Now Hiring Entry Level CDL-A DriversRecent Grads Make up to $80K in your First Year!No Experience...
- Customer Service Representative
U Haul — Columbus,OHReturn to Job SearchCustomer Service RepresentativeAre you a people person? Do you love helping others? U-Haul is in search of friendly, motivated people for the position of Customer Service Representative....
- Inventory Associate
CarMax — Columbus,OH6025 - Columbus GA - 6463 Veterans Parkway, Columbus, Georgia, 31909CarMax, the way your career should be!Position OverviewAs a Reconditioning Associate I - Satellite, you play a vital role in...
- Warehouse Clerk
Crane Worldwide Logistics — Lockbourne,OHEssential Job Functions* Performs data entry, and prepares standard reports & spreadsheets* Collects, organizes, records, and files information.* Performs Rating & Billing duties* Other duties as assignedOther Skills & Abilities*...
- Customer Service Representative
Rowleys Wholesale — Columbus,OHDescription Overview This position is responsible for interacting with and retaining customers by answering product and service questions, suggesting information about other products and services. The...
- Forklift Operators - Immediate Start
SMX Staffing — Columbus,OHWith Staff Management | SMX, you'll get a weekly paycheck, learn new skills, meet new people, and work with a great management team in a clean and safe environment.SMX has...
- Dock Worker / Forklift Operator, Part-Time
ABF — Columbus,OHJob Description Dock Workers are responsible for loading and unloading trailers for the purpose of transporting a wide variety of cargo, moving cargo, driving a forklift, or using a pallet...
- Warehouse & Inventory Coordinator - Columbus, OH
MSCCN — Columbus,OHJob Description ATTENTION MILITARY AFFILIATED JOB SEEKERS - Our organization works with partner companies to source qualified talent for their open roles. The following position is available to Veterans, Transitioning...
- Warehouse Associate - Loader/Unloader - 2nd Shift - $20.00/Hour
Cintas — Columbus,OHRequisition Number: 226261Job DescriptionCintas is seeking a Warehouse Associate - Loader/Unloader to support the Rental Division. Loader/Unloaders are responsible for driving company trucks to designated areas in the facility for...
- Supervisor, Fulfillment (Shipping & Receiving)
1-800-FLOWERS.COM — Columbus,OHPosition OverviewThe Fulfillment Supervisor (Shipping & Receiving) provides frontline leadership for both inbound and outbound operations at the Obetz facility. This role is responsible for overseeing receiving, inventory movement, picking,...
- Substitute Cook/Cashier
Grandview Heights City School District — Columbus,OHGrandview Heights Schools is seeking a substitute cook/cashier! Contributes to the effective and efficient operation of the food service department by adhering to all safety and health requirements in relation...
- Vendor Managed Inventory Specialist
MSC Industrial Direct Co. — Columbus,OHBUILD A BETTER CAREER WITH MSCServing customers and our community starts with the best people doing their best work. That is precisely what we have created at MSC Industrial Supply...
- Inventory Control Associate - Overnight - Full-Time + OT
CosmoProf — Columbus,OHJob Description Inventory Control Associate - Overnight - Full-Time + OT Sally Beauty Holdings - Distribution Center Location: 4309 Janitrol Rd., Columbus, OH...
- Dock Worker/Forklift Operator - Starting Pay $27.50 - (Tues-Sat 7:00pm - 5:00am)
Old Dominion Freight Line — Columbus,OHAre you someone who never rests on their laurels, always strives to go above and beyond, and is committed to keeping your PROMISES? Do you appreciate a company culture that...
- Production Operator Training Program (No Experience Needed & Job Placement Support)
Columbus State Community College — New Albany,OHProduction Operator Training Program (No Experience Needed & Job Placement Support) Looking to start a career in advanced manufacturing with no experience required? Columbus State Community College is recruiting for...
- Dishwasher
Smokey Bones — Grove City,OHAre you looking for a place that celebrates YOU for being YOU? Do you want to work with people that are fun and work as a team? Where you have...
- Customer Service Representative
Ritchie Bros. — Grove City,OH* The Customer Service Representative will provide exceptional customer service, answer inquiries, process payments and other sale day activities.* Responsible for organizing all keys / organizing and filing documents by...
- Cook
Lutheran Social Services of Central Ohio — Columbus,OHCookFull Time | 11am - 7pm | Including every other weekendPay: $17/hourLutheran Social Services of Central Ohio is currently seeking a Cook for CHOICES for Victims of Domestic Violence in...
- Warehouse Inventory Associate
G&J Pepsi-Cola Bottlers — Columbus,OHInventory Associate Sunday - Thursday, 1st Shift Position Summary To serve our internal customer by ensuring all warehouse inventory is counted and reconciled accurately and maintained according to established...
- Customer Service Administrator
Towne Properties Associates — Columbus,OHApplyJob TypeFull-timeDescriptionLove Where You Work!At Towne Properties, we don't just build communities-we build careers. Family-owned since 1961, we've spent over 60 years creating Great Places to Live, Work, Shop &...
- PT Dockworker- Inbound- 4 AM Start
Pitt Ohio Express — Grove City,OHOverviewPITT OHIO is a family owned transportation company with a long standing commitment to safety, service and respect for our employees. We are currently seeking individuals to join our team...
- Bartender (Part-Time), Spark Lobby Bar - Hilton Columbus Downtown
Hilton Hotels — Columbus,OHJobID: 209470Category: Food and BeverageJobSchedule: Part timePosted Date: 2026-06-05T21:30:09+00:00JobShift:Equal Opportunity Employer: EOE, including disability/vetsExceptional Hospitality Starts with YouPicture yourself brightening someone's day.
- Auto Glass Installation Technician Trainee
Safelite — Lewis Center,OHDoes this position interest you? You should apply – even if you don't match every single requirement! We're known as an auto glass company. That's the focus of what we...
- Produce Associate
Wal Mart — Reynoldsburg,OH* Be a Team Member: Maintains up-to-date knowledge of the products; collaborating with cross functional teams and helping educate other associates on tools, tasks, and resources; communicating effectively and developing...
- Senior IT Engineer - VF
ApTask Global Workforce — Columbus,OHAptask Global Workforce (AGW) is seeking a Senior IT Engineer - VF for a contract to hire position with a Major Utility Company located in Columbus, OH. This is a...