Have you ever received a call from staffing agencies or hiring managers that clearly undervalued your skill level? It’s pretty disappointing to get a call from your dream company in the hopes of being interviewed for that Executive Management position only to find they want to meet with you for their Executive Assistant job.
You don’t want that job but you want to work for the company. How do you gracefully decline an opportunity that you’re overqualified for?
Thrivas, a leader among staffing agencies in Broward County, has a few tips. These tips are directly from our recruiters. Yep, they may have called you and misread a key point on your resume or overlooked your education achievements in error. We may have gotten the hopes up for applicants who knew we were recruiting for a certain Fortune 500 company or international organization that they want to be a part of. Only to find the employment opportunity does not suit their skill level or experience. Although it is very rare, we have made mistakes.
The job seekers who get angry and rush off the phone in a huff (appalled that an error could be made regarding their amazingness) may never get a return call. When that dream job does finally open up the job seeker will be remembered as unprofessional and emotionally incapable of handling sour situations in a positive manner. Hanging up on the staffing agency that is recruiting for your dream company? That’s not very harmonious with the “able to work well under pressure” or “poised, professional and level headed in the most stressful situations” that you have typed out on your resume.
So how do you handle this delicate situation in the hopes of being considered for employment opportunities that meet your expectations, salary or career goals? Well, our Broward County Staffing Agency has had some great responses that earned a call back and it was because the approach was so tactful we said, “Wow, now that’s a professional. Let me earmark that resume”. That person went from undervalued to our go-to resume for the next opening.
A simple statement such as “I am so glad you called. I have done a lot of research on your company and would love to be considered, however I feel that (XYZ qualifications) would make me more suited for a position such as…” or a more direct but tactful response “Although my qualifications and salary make me overqualified for this particular position I would like to have my information kept on file with your company. Possibly for (XYZ opportunity).
This allows you to decline in a way that does not embarrass the recruiter for their error while offering you the opportunity to outline your skill set AND take a moment to outline where your interests are with the staffing company.
Find a job by searching below
- Surveillance Patrol Officer
GardaWorld — Columbus,OHGardaWorld - - Responsibilities: Monitor security systems to detect any suspicious activity; Document observed events and incidents, writing detailed reports; Respond quickly to incidents or potential threats; Conduct regular patrols...
- Store Assistant, Full Time
Circle K — Pickerington,OHCircle K - 29 Hill Road - Responsibilities: Assist the Store Manager with oversight of the Stationstore operations; Help with hiring, supervising and working with the staff to accomplish daily...
- Servers - Easton Town Center
Northstar Cafe — Columbus,OHWorking at Northstar Cafe is much more than just a job. It's the chance to become an important member of a close-knit team, responsible for shaping the experience at a...
- Material Handler
Baesman — Columbus,OHMaterial HandlerBaesman Group has an excellent opportunity for someone wanting a career with a first class printing and marketing company. We work with the top national retailers, universities, hospitality and...
- Shipping and Receiving
Kelly Services — Groveport,OHKelly Services, Inc. - - Responsibilities: Processing data entry tasks related to shipping and receiving units across multiple systems; Handling material parts as part of regular warehouse operations, including receiving,...
- Custodian - Various Shifts
CSI International — Columbus,OHCSI International - - Responsibilities: Remove trash and waste from the facility; Vacuum, mop floors, dust surfaces and clean restrooms; Stock restrooms and maintain cleaning supplies; Clean floors using various...
- Customer Service Associate - Nights/Weekends
Raising Cane's — Columbus,OHStarting hiring pay at: $15.00 As an important part of our team, Customer Service Associates impact all areas of the customer experience. As the name suggests, your main priority is...
- Van Driver
Hallcon — Columbus,OHHallcon - - Responsibilities: Safely and reliably transport railroad crews to assigned locations; Conduct thorough pre-trip and post-trip inspections of the assigned vehicle; Utilize navigation tools effectively; Adhere to Hallcon's...
- AAA Retail Sales Associate (In-Store Sales)
AAA — Worthington,OHUnlock Your Sales Potential at AAA Club Alliance! Are you passionate about delivering exceptional service while driving sales success? Join our team and be part of a dynamic retail environment...
- Need Work? Want to help people? Become a Senior Caregiver
MissionCare — Dublin,OHHiring Full-Time Caregivers (PCA/HHA/CNA/Companions) - Flex Schedules Openings for caregivers to work within a home care or assisted living setting.We are an approved training site – welcoming experienced caregivers and...
- Material Handler Level 2P
Kasmo Global — Columbus,OHWarehouse Associate Performs the physical or administrative tasks involved in the shipping, receiving, storing and distributing of materials, parts, supplies and equipment. Unpacks and checks goods received against purchase orders...
- Front Desk Supervisor
Twin Tier Hospitality — Columbus,OHFront Desk Supervisor Double Tree by Hilton Worthington - Columbus, OH 43235 Overview Position Type Full Time Job Shift First/Day Second/Afternoon Third/Night Education Level High School Category Hospitality - Hotel...
- Summer Work Crew
Educational Service Center Of Central Ohio — Columbus,OHPosition Type: Maintenance Date Posted: 3/10/2026 Location: District Date Available: TBD District: Delaware City...
- Food Manufacturing Production Associate 1st Shift
DONATOS — Columbus,OHPosition Summary:The Production Associate is responsible for the safe and efficient production of our finished goods. Priorities of the role include personal and team safety, food safety, and product quality....
- Data Center Associate Pharmacy(A shift M-F 6am-2:30pm)
DSV — New Albany,OHData Center Associate Pharmacy (A Shift M-F 6am-2:30pm) Location: USA - New Albany, 1101 Beech Rd Division: Solutions Job Posting Title: Data Center Associate Pharmacy (A shift M-F 6am-2:30pm) Time...
- Part-Time Trash Collector - Evening Shift -Pickup Truck Required
VALET LIVING — Columbus,OHJob description A personal and reliable open-bed pickup truck or vehicle hauling a trailer is REQUIRED for this position. Are you looking for a part-time job that keeps you moving...
- Retail Stocking Associate - Part Time
Burlington Stores — Grove City,OHStocking Associate If you want an exciting job with one of the largest off-price retail stores in the nation, join the Burlington Stores, Inc. as a Stocking Associate! Are you...
- Warehouse Associate
Grimco — Columbus,OHCompany Description Do you want to work for a company where the people are the purpose? At Grimco, our Warehouse Associates aren't just part of a team they're a vital...
- Dishwasher
The Capital Grille — Columbus,OHThe Capital Grille - 1827 Olentangy River Road - Responsibilities: Wash, store and rack plateware, glassware, utensils, pots, pans, and other smallwares and equipment for the restaurant; Maintain sparkling clean...
- Seasonal Event Staff
Laz Parking — Columbus,OHLAZ Parking - - Responsibilities: Greet customers and provide excellent customer service; Collect parking fees and provide correct change; Answer questions about parking and building areas; Complete daily reports; Assist...
- Janitor
Trillium Staffing — Groveport,OHTrillium Staffing - - Responsibilities: Clean and maintain offices, restrooms, and lobby areas; Sanitize high-touch surfaces, including doors and windows within reach; Operate floor cleaning equipment; Ensure all areas meet...
- Maintenance $17.00 Starting Wage
McDonald's — Circleville,OHMcDonald's - 1300 South Court Street - Responsibilities: Filtering oil fryers daily; Maintaining outside grounds; Clean equipment, inside and outside windows, stock rooms and restrooms; Unload delivery truck 2 times...
- In-Store Product Ambassador
COLUMBUS WORTHINGTON AIR — Columbus,OHCompany Name: Columbus Worthington Air Overview: Pay: $19 - $20 per hour + commission Earning...
- Hotel Housekeeper (PT or FT)
Hospitality Staffing Solutions — Columbus,OH[Room Attendant / Cleaner] - Up to $18.75/hr to Start (Weekly pay + Full Benefits) / Part-time or Full-time Hours / Multiple Shifts Available - Hospitality Staffing Solutions, located renowned...
- MEMORIAL TOURNAMENT SERVER | CAMERON MITCHELL PREMIER EVENTS
cameron mitchell — Columbus,OHCAMERON MITCHELL RESTAURANTS is seeking Servers to join our team for the Memorial Tournament! Who are We? We are Great People Delivering Genuine...
- Painter
Friedman Management — Columbus,OHPainter Alexander Hamilton Plaza Apartments - Columbus, OH 43213 Overview Position Type Full Time Category Skilled Labor - Trades Description Do you have experience with interior painting and drywall repair...
- Direct Support Professional
Beacon Specialized Living — Columbus,OHBeacon Specialized Living - - Responsibilities: Assist with daily living skills and personal care; Support community engagement and recreational activities; Prepare meals and maintain a clean, organized home environment; Transport...
- Dishwasher
BJ's Restaurants — Columbus,OHOverviewOpen interviews conducted daily - Walk-ins are WelcomeHiring ImmediatelyWe value Gracious Hospitality in everything we do, it starts with you! Our team members are the not-so-secret ingredient in crafting memorable...
- Awake Overnight Direct Care Staff
Sevita — Lancaster,OHSevita - - Responsibilities: Provide overnight awake direct care to individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities; Develop real, meaningful relationships with the individuals you serve; Support participants with developmental...
- Forklift Operator - All shifts
KDC/ONE — New Albany,OHForklift Operator The Forklift Operator is responsible for operating Powered Industrial Trucks (PIT) to pick, stage, load and stock materials, components, and finish goods in and out of the warehouse...
- Third Shift Customer Service
Planet Fitness — Columbus,OHThe Overnight Customer Service Representative will be responsible for creating a positive member experience by providing a superior level of customer service to Planet Fitness members, prospective members and guests....
- Customer Service Associate
Dollar Tree Family Dollar - Dollar Tree — Columbus,OHYour positive, friendly disposition and eagerness to get things done make you the right person for our Customer Service Associate II position. Join our team today and lets create an...
- Customer Service Representative
Lower Lights Health — Columbus,OHABOUT LLCHCLower Lights Christian Health Center (LLCHC) transforms the overall health of Central Ohio, serving one individual at a time. We are focused on whole-person wellness, available to ALL in...
- Plasma Operator - 2nd Shift
Mettler Toledo — Columbus,OHOur Opening and Your ResponsibilitiesThe Masstron Producing Organization (MTMS) designs, develops, and produces products within the METTLER TOLEDO Vehicle and Heavy Capacity product families and serves in direct support of...
- Front Desk Agent | Towneplace Suites Columbus North-OSU
Shaner Hotel Group — Columbus,OHJob Description Be available to work a flexible schedule, including weekends, holidays, and varied shifts. Handle guest complaints ensuring guest satisfaction. Process all check-ins and check-outs according to established...
- Warehouse Material Handler
Graybar Electric Company — Columbus,OHOperate warehouse equipment such as pallet jacks, forklifts and push carts. Receive and store incoming material in accordance with warehouse management system process. Select, pack and palletize shipments. Sort and...
- Carpenter
Singleton Construction, LLC — Columbus,OHCarpenter Opportunities Through continued growth, Singleton Construction has opportunities across our field team for committed and hardworking carpenters - from carpenter helper level to lead carpenters. We have two distinct...
- Luxury Assisted Living Jobs - Resident Caregivers & CNAs
myCNAjobs — Columbus,OHNeed Work? Want to help people? Become a Senior Caregiver We recognize that many individuals have been laid off due to the coronavirus or may be seeking additional hours.We can...
- Home Care Aide
A PLUS HEALTH CARE — Westerville,OHA Plus Health Care - - Responsibilities: Help clients stay in their homes and perform personal care and daily living tasks; Light housekeeping, laundry, or running errands for clients; Meal...
- Stock Team Member - Kirkland's Home - Part Time
Kirklands — Columbus,OHStock Team Member The primary responsibility of a Stock Team Member is to assist with freight flow process, backroom organization, salesfloor replenishment, and price changes. This position requires a high...